Standards


Objectives of lecture:

  1. History of standards: spatial data transfer to interoperability
  2. VPF versus SDTS
  3. road to Open GIS (OGC)

Standards resources

NIMA has a lot of standards, largely for "products" (the actual data) as well as the encoding methods...

Similarly, USGS has promulgated "standards" for each of their products...

SDTS was a major effort of the US government, BUT largely going unused...

FGDC has a lot of standards activity, much of it about metadata, as much as the data transfer

International Standards Organization (ISO) has TC211, working on a world level. (much of the documents are NOT available without a password). [paper on Refernce Model] The USA is represented at ISO by the NCIST technical committee L1... (it gets pretty confusing, acutally it is the same old cast of characters...)

The industry (and some other players) are working on Open GIS through a consortium.

a list of standards sites (USGS).


History of the US effort on Spatial Data Transfer Standards


There is never an "origin, but 21 years ago gives some sense of the long-term futility of these efforts...

1982

National Committee for Digital Cartographic Data Standards (NCDCDS) created by American Congress on Surveying and Mapping (professional organization) because US Geological Survey (USGS) National Mapping Division (NMD) asked ACSM to create a standard for 'digital cartographic data exchange' to respond to general request from National Bureau of Standards for 'geoscience standards'.
Canadian Council on Surveying and Mapping withdraws draft to await US effort.

1983

due to the General Accounting Office report on Duplicative Federal Mapping, the Office of Management and Budget revisits A-16, the mandate controlling mapping efforts. A Federal Interagency Coordinating Committee for Digital Cartography (FICCDC) is created. Interior is named lead and USGS NMD operates it subject to some internal squabbling with Bureau of Land Management... FICCDC was also charged with creating standards. (see the abortive FGEF)

1980s Digital Geographic Information Working Group (DGIWG) created by NATO, representatives of military mapping organizations (including Australia, etc.)

1986

UK Working Party to produce national transfer standards, an informal group organized by Ordnance Survey (OS). National Transfer Standard adopted 1990?
ATKIS German cadastral mapping standard, specifies everything, schema, proceedures, but no software can really do it...

1989

FICCDC renames itself to Federal Geographic Data Committee (FGDC),
NMD still in charge.

1990

Spatial Data Transfer Standard generated by NCDCDS for USGS, reworked by FGDC Working Group to be submitted to NIST
Working Group on Data Organization chaired by T. Nyerges, Federal Register Dec 90
Uses ISO 8211 (a self-describing interchange encoding scheme) as a vehicle.
Includes Data Quality Specification (virtually unaltered from NCDCDS)

1991

DIGEST the military (NATO) transfer standard. adopted by French IGN based on ISO 8211 (version A) or ISO 8824(B)

VPF Vector Product Format: designed for DMA (now NIMA) Digital Chart of the World. adopted by DGIWG as DIGEST-C. Not an exchange standard, but a format for direct use of database from CD-ROM.

1992

SDTS (US National Standard: FIPS 173) Spatial Data Transfer Standard
adopted by NIST as FIPS PUB 173-1 1994 (1994?)

1994 (a big year for standards)

FGDC adopts Content Standards for Geospatial Metadata (incompatible w. SDTS)

Spatial Archive and Interchange Format (SAIF) adopted by Canadians, submitted to ISO as a part of SQL/MM (multi-media) standard! No longer visible, sorry.... This triggered the creation of TC211... (multi-inheritance, OO approach...) and in its private consultant form too; now called FME?
1994-6 Open GIS Foundation (also OGConsortium) issues working papers and concept documents.


1996

TC287 of CEN draft stadards, related to ISO211 process... (it never ends)


1998

ISO TC211 starts issuing draft standards; proposal for harmonization between TC 211 and OGC...

TC 287 adopted 1997/98 as "prestandards"

ANSI adopts SDTS as ANSI NCITS 320-1998, ratified by the American National Standards Institute (ANSI) June 9, 1998. FIPS updated to reflect newer version.

EXPRESS as basis for ISO/CEN, etc. ?

2000 and onwards

more committees meeting all over the world...

ongoing process at ISO...



SDTS

Set up the problem as "exchange" (transfer)

VPF

Set up the problem as "use" (directly off CD)

OGC

sets up problem as interoperability

another view on interoperability (original UCGIS agenda <scroll down>; now it is called "data fusion"...)



Index from here: Next lecture | Schedule | Questions |

Version of 25 February 2003